3 min read
Understanding Restitution in California Criminal Cases
Bail House , Scott-Licensed Agent : Published
When a criminal case ends in a conviction, the sentence often includes more than probation or jail time. If someone suffered a financial loss because of the crime, the court will usually order restitution. For many people, it's the part of the sentence that lasts the longest. Here's what restitution is in California, how the amount is decided, and how it gets paid.
Restitution Repays the Victim's Losses
Restitution is money the person convicted is ordered to pay to the victim to cover financial losses caused by the crime. California's Constitution gives crime victims a right to restitution, and state law generally requires courts to order it whenever a victim suffered an economic loss. The goal isn't punishment; it's repairing the financial harm.
What It Can Cover
Restitution can include the value of stolen or damaged property, medical and dental bills, counseling costs, lost wages, and other out-of-pocket expenses tied to the crime. It's based on actual, documented losses. Pain and suffering generally isn't part of criminal restitution, though a victim may pursue that separately in civil court.
Restitution vs. the Restitution Fine
People often confuse two different things. Direct restitution goes to the specific victim and matches their losses. Separately, California has long required a restitution fine in criminal cases, a set amount within a range that helps fund services for crime victims in general. They're ordered differently, and paying one doesn't satisfy the other, so it's worth asking the attorney to explain exactly what was ordered.
How the Amount Is Decided
The amount is usually based on information from the victim, such as receipts, repair estimates, medical bills, and pay records, often gathered by the probation department or the prosecutor. If the defense disagrees with the amount, it can ask for a restitution hearing, where the judge reviews the evidence and decides. Sometimes the final amount is set weeks or months after sentencing, once all the losses are known.
Plea Deals Can Include Restitution for Dismissed Charges
In some plea agreements, the person agrees to pay restitution for losses connected to charges that are being dismissed as part of the deal. If that's part of an offer, the attorney should explain it clearly before the plea is entered, since it can affect the total amount owed.
How Payments Usually Work
Few people can pay restitution all at once, so courts commonly set up a payment plan, often managed through the county's collections office or the probation department. Payments are made on a schedule, and records are kept of every payment. Keeping receipts and paying consistently, even in small amounts, makes a real difference.
What If You Can't Afford the Payments?
For direct victim restitution, the full amount of the victim's loss is generally ordered regardless of the person's finances. But how it's paid can often be adjusted. If payments become impossible because of a job loss or other hardship, the person or their attorney should contact the court or collections office right away to ask about changing the payment schedule. Simply stopping payments without saying anything is what causes the most problems.
Where the Money Goes
Payments usually go through the court, probation, or a county collections office, which then sends the money on to the victim. That's why it's important to pay only through the official channels listed in the court order, not directly to the victim, unless the court specifically allows it. Paying the right way makes sure every dollar is recorded and credited.
Help for Victims
If you're on the other side of a case and owed restitution, California's victim compensation program and the local victim services office can explain how collection works and what other help may be available.
Restitution Doesn't End When Probation Does
Many people are surprised to learn that unpaid restitution can outlast probation. In California, a restitution order is enforceable like a civil judgment, which means the victim or the state can continue to collect it after the case is over. Unpaid restitution can also affect things like requests to end probation early. Paying it off is one of the most important steps toward truly putting a case behind you.
A Few Common Questions
Is restitution the same as a fine? No. Restitution repays the victim's actual losses; fines go to the state or county.
Who decides how much restitution I owe? The judge, usually based on documentation from the victim. The defense can ask for a hearing to challenge the amount.
Can I pay restitution in installments? Usually, yes. Courts commonly set up payment plans through county collections or probation.
What if I lose my job and can't pay? Contact the court or collections office right away to ask about changing the payment schedule.
Does restitution go away when probation ends? No. Unpaid restitution can still be collected after the case is over.
Sentencing brings a lot of new obligations, and it helps to have people in your corner from the very beginning. Our Auburn team has been helping families through every stage of a case since 1973. Call us any time, day or night, and we will help you every step of the way.